The chin-up and pull-up are among the top upper body exercises for developing strength and power. While they’re both similar in their movements, they can be used in your programming at different times for different reasons.
The Differences Between Chin-ups and Pull-ups
While chin-ups are just a variation of pull-ups, most know them as completely separate entities. The movements are very similar, but there is a fundamental difference between the two, and that’s hand placement.
If you’re someone who’s new to lifting, or these exercises – don’t fret. For this scenario, we’ll pretend the chin-up and pull-up are both completely separate movements. An easy way I teach newer trainees to remember the difference between the chin-up and pull-up is this…
Think about your hand position when scratching your chin, your palm is facing you – that’s the hand placement for standard chin-ups. Now turn your palm out and try to scratch your chin, you can’t (well, at least) – that’s a pull-up. When in doubt, think about scratching your chin, palms in means chin-up; palms out, pull-up.
The muscles activated are similar in each of the movements; the small differences lie in the rate they’re activated and the mechanics needed to perform the exercise. A study that was performed in 2014 compared the electromyography (EMG) ratings between a conventional pull-up and chin-up.
Chin Up & Pull Up EMG Ratings
Latissimus Dorsi: 117-130%
Biceps Brachii: 78-96%
Lower Trapezius: 45-56%
Pectoralis Major: 44-57%
Erector Spinae: 39-41%
External Oblique: 31-35%
The authors pointed out that the pectoralis major and biceps brachii EMG ratings were significantly higher during the chin-up. In regards to the pull-up, the authors noted that the lower trapezius had higher EMG ratings.
Where To Start with Chin-ups and Pull-ups
If performing full range of motion chin-up and pull-ups are tough for you, there are a few ways you can work towards building up the strength to do so. A lot of coaches will have athletes perform banded chin-ups and pull-ups – while there’s a time and place for it – I see an issue with this method.
The band is taking away the hardest part of the movement (the concentric/upward motion) and then aiding in the eccentric. At no point does the athlete or client learn how to hold their own weight. Instead try these tips…
1. Eccentric Work
Climb and get yourself into the top of the pull-up and chin-up, then work on lowering yourself at a slower tempo. This will support your ability to handle your own weight, along with build muscle.
Beginners: From peak position to full extension work to lower yourself at a tempo of 4-seconds, then add time accordingly to your abilities.
Climb to the top and perform a hold at peak position, lower yourself a little, perform another hold with arms at 90 degrees. Proceed to lower yourself to nearly full extension, think 150 degrees, and perform another hold. You can add as many positions as you’d like, for beginners, I recommend starting with three.
Beginners: Start with a tempo of 4:4:4 and then work up with your tempo, sets, and reps.
When To Program Each Movement
This is where different views and training goals will clash, but for someone who’s looking to build power, strength, and a bigger upper body, these exercises are great additions to any program. Ideally you’ll want to add them to your pulling, or back days. In addition, you may want to put them higher in the hierarchy of your exercise list. What this means, is that they take precedence over exercises that don’t offer the same bang for the buck.
When you’re working with weighted chin-ups and pull-ups, it should be noted that these can be taxing on the nervous system. This being said, cater your reps and sets to what you can handle while stilling being effective, and to what your training goals are.
Parallel chin-up (palms facing each other) – This is a great movement for beginners, this variation feels a lot more natural during the upward motion for a lot of newer trainees.
Towel pull-up – Wrap towels around a bar, grab them at their ends and perform pull-ups. This is an excellent variation for building grip strength.
One-arm chin-up/pull-up – Possibly the hardest variation, but not impossible to learn.
Plyo pull-up – This is an awesome upper body plyometric exercise, pull yourself up like a regular pull-up, but as you reach the peak of the pull you’re going to explosively finish the movement. Once you hit the explosive portion of the pull, let go of the bar and grab again lowering yourself in a controlled manner for the eccentric portion.
Mixed grip pull-up – Much like the deadlift grip, you’ll have one palm in and one out. Perform a normal pull-up with this grip, make sure you hit the same amount of reps on each side.
Close grip pull-up/chin-up – Bring your hands close to the point where they’re almost touching (bigger chested people, get as close as possible), this is a great variation when you’re trying to target the biceps.
1.5 chin up – Start with a normal chin-up grip, you’re then going to pull yourself up to 90 degrees and stop, proceed to lower yourself down to full extension, and then finish the movement. In practical terms, think as if your pull-up has a stutter.
These exercises are great additions to any program, with countless variations and reasons to start using them – I think it’s crazy people leave them out of their daily routines. Whether your goal is to gain strength, power, or size, grip the bar and start pulling.
Editors note: This article is an op-ed. The views expressed herein are the authors and don’t necessarily reflect the views of BarBend. Claims, assertions, opinions, and quotes have been sourced exclusively by the author.
The post Chin-ups Versus Pull-ups: Why the Difference Is Important appeared first on BarBend.