Sumo Versus Conventional Deadlift: Your Definitive Guide

The deadlift is one of the best exercises for building muscle, strength, and all around athleticism. This lift involves some of the most animalistic traits humans possess, which are raw strength and power. It’s modern man’s (& woman’s) way of fluffing their feathers and asserting dominance, grit, and innate ability to provide.

When someone says, “Should I deadlift?” the answer is a no brainer (assuming one’s back is healthy), and that is: of course. Yet, the answer changes when someone says, “Should I pull sumo or conventional?” Then the answer takes a weird form, which is comprised of multiple opinions and logics.

This article isn’t intended to claim one is better than the other in terms of back strength or record legitimacy. Save the sumo versus conventional deadlift debate for the comments section.

For this article we’ll cover the kinematic difference between the lifts and when to use each.

Sumo Deadlift Form and Conventional Deadlift Form: Electromyography & Kinematics

The form differences between conventional and sumo deadlifts are pretty recognizable, and even the newest lifter can generally point out form differences between each deadlift. What a newer lifter may struggle with is pointing out the differences between targeted muscles and force transfer.

In come kinematic differences and the rates at which our muscles fire. The sumo deadlift relies on recruiting the hips, glutes, and legs to initiate the first portion of the pull, while the conventional has a more equal balance between the lower back and hamstrings.

Each pull hits similar muscles throughout their full ranges of motion. In fact, a study conducted in 2002 found only a few differences between each deadlift and the rate at which different muscles fired. Researchers used electromyography (EMG) ratings to record muscle fire rate and tracked 16 different muscle sites.

Data from: Escamilla, R. F., Francisco, A. F., Kayes, A. V., Speer, K. P. & Moorman, C. T. (2002). An electromyographic analysis of sumo and conventional style deadlifts.

Of the above data there are four muscles that show somewhat of significant differences. First, the vastus medialis and lateralis (outer/inner quad muscles) are higher in the sumo pull, which makes sense as this pull incorporates more legs and a slightly more forward lean.

Second, the tibial anterior and medial gastrocnemius are different in each pull, which suggests the posterior and anterior portions of the lower limbs are differently engaged between both styles.

A video posted by Jake Boly (@jake_boly) on Jan 28, 2017 at 2:03pm PST

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

Another cool EMG observation this study made was the difference in muscles firing when wearing a belt and not. To no surprise, researchers found that not wearing a belt made a significant decrease on the rectus abdominis and external oblique fire rates. If you’re ever wondering, “Should I wear a belt?” check out this article.

When Should You Use Sumo Versus Conventional

This above statement is such a loaded question. In reality, a strength athlete can benefit from – and in most cases – should utilize both styles of deadlift. To help me answer this big question I reached out to two strength coaches known for working with some of the strongest athletes in the game:

John Gaglione, strength coach and owner of Gaglione Strength in Farmingdale, New York, and Paulie Steinman, strength coach and owner of South Brooklyn Weightlifting Club.

I asked each coach two big questions. The first question was…

1. As a strength coach, how do you choose whether someone should conventional or sumo deadlift? Do you make the call or do you let the athlete decide?

John GaglioneI let my athletes experiment and decide what feels comfortable to them. I will offer advice on what I think looks mechanically better for their body and leverages, but at the end of the day the athlete needs to be comfortable and confident in the stance and form they decide to use.

To keep things simple. Ask yourself two questions.

  • Which one looks more “athletic” and feels more natural?
  • In which stance can I lift more weight?

If you answered yes to both questions you should probably stick with that stance.

If you are a competitive powerlifter you goal is to lift the most amount of weight possible. So that should be your number one deciding factor.

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

It is possible in the long term that might turn into your stronger stance but you just need to spend more time. Sumo deadlifting requires more hip and glute strength and conventional deadlifting requires more hamstring and lower back strength.

Both will require a degree of leg (quad) upper back (traps, lats, etc) and overall core and grip strength. So maybe your from is up to snuff but your stabilizer muscles or supporting muscle groups aren’t strong enough for you to truly express your strength quite yet.

Paulie SteinmanAs a rule, unless there is a glaring anthropometric issue, I will start the lifter off with conventional. Ultimately I want the lifter to use the setup that will allow them to lift the most amount of weight as efficiently as possible. That may end up being Sumo. Sumo is just as hard as conventional.

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

I don’t ever want a lifter to pull sumo because they are taking a shortcut to lifting more weight. The best form is often not immediately apparent and it also depends on how long the lifter has been training. I don’t ever let a lifter use a particular form or technique because it looks cool or they see their favorite powerlifter pulling that way on Instagram.

Jake Boly: Do you have any methods or coaching techniques that you employ to test an athlete that you think may be suspect of that specific scenario?

Paulie SteinmanIt’s not very difficult to test an athlete that I think may be suspect of that specific scenario. I’ll go after the mental component and I’ll ask them why they think that sumo is that the way that they should pull. I’ll take over if they don’t have a good answer. If I am feeling patient, I’ll explain that it’s a long process for a lifter to get comfortable with their form.

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

It rarely happens overnight. So, at best, what my lifter is seeing is usually the result of years and years of practice and tinkering. At worst, it’s just crappy technique and there is not much to learn from it. There not much sense in trying to copy that. It’s like trying on someone else’s well worn pair of shoes and expecting them to fit perfectly.

2. Are there ways a strength athlete can test to see which deadlift they’d be better at?

John GaglioneWhen switching stances or trying a new it is best to start with lighter weight and higher reps off blocks or mats and work your way down to the floor in order to build strength while ingraining proper position.

That being said let’s pose this situation. Perhaps you are stronger conventional at this time but your sumo looks a lot cleaner mechanically.

If you can move cleaner in a particular pattern you will be able to train the lift with more intensity, volume and frequency which will allow for greater strength gains in the long run.

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

In either stance it is very important to move the barbell in a straight line of the mid foot. If there is excessive lateral movement as the bar travel up the body you will never be as efficient and by able to truly express your strength to the fullest on the platform. You need to find a stance and technique that allows for the straighter bar path.

Limb lengths and torso lengths can absolutely play a role, but at the end of the day you need to use the stance that feels best and helps you reach your goal.  At the end of the day you can’t control your body type, but you can control your attitude, technique, and the amount of muscle mass and strength you have in certain areas.

Focus on what you can control and not what you can’t. If you are a competitive powerlifter use the stance that is going to give you the highest total at the meet.

Paulie SteinmanI don’t have any specific tests beyond my eyes, the bar speed, and feedback from the lifter. Very old school, I know. I think that the lifter should lift with their competition lift at least 80% of the time since it is also a skill that they are developing.

//platform.instagram.com/en_US/embeds.js

The balance of the time can be used for the alternate version of their deadlift. It also depends if the lifter is competing equipped or raw but that can be another conversation too.

Takeaway Messages

Both the sumo and conventional deadlift can be used to support athleticism, strength, and power in athletes. Each deadlift will target similar musculature, but will vary in certain areas dependent on the way each move is initiated.

If you’re a competitive lifter, then utilize your competition stance more often. For recreational strength athletes, the utilization of both a little more equally can be beneficial.

Benefits of sumo deadlift and benefits of conventional deadlifting vary, but they each have their place.

If you’re still having trouble deciding between lifts, then test both of them out, and use some of the tips referenced above to help decide.

The post Sumo Versus Conventional Deadlift: Your Definitive Guide appeared first on BarBend.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s